Skip to main content
Elisa Batista's picture

Inside scoop: I facebooked and tweeted the story about the Ohio mom who became a convicted felon after she used her parents' address to send her daughters to a public school there. According to a very close source, the mother was an employee at the Akron schools district she refused to send her daughter to and while they are supportive of her as "you can imagine what it is doing for their image when a staff member won't send her kids there." The source also provided this inside scoop: "50 other folks were charged with the same offense (sending their child to Copley when they lived somewhere else), all 50 took the plea and ended up without a felony record after paying a fine. While I sympathize with a mother wanting the best for her child, it's not true that she wasn't offered a plea deal."

Which leads me to the point of this column: this mom and the "50 other folks" shouldn't be charged with an offense for wanting a better education for their children. It is time to take down the borders to our country's best schools and give ALL parents, regardless of their ability to pay property taxes, school choice. -Elisa

I support school choice. I think parents, regardless of where they live, should have the right to enroll their children in any public school, and if they can afford it, parochial or private school. If they deem that homeschooling is best for their family, then I say go for it.

But here is my worry about using taxpayer money to fund anything other than the public schools: I worry that it would come at the expense of dismantling traditional public schools and forcing an exclusive group of parents into only private options. Please see our healthcare system, which is a mess and expensive. Oh, and it doesn't cover everyone.

That said, at the very least, there shouldn't be borders to a good education. Please see the case of Kelley Williams-Bolar, an African-American mom in Ohio, who is now a convicted felon and served a nine-day jail sentence for using her parents' address to send her daughters to a better school district.

She is being called the "Rosa Parks of education reform" and for good reason:

"The 40-year old mother became the first person in U.S. history to have been convicted of 'theft' and 'tampering with records' for sending her children to a better school outside of her designated school district. Using the address of the children’s grandfather, who is a resident and pays taxes to Copley Township, Williams-Bolar enrolled her two daughters into the Copley Township school district, a much whiter and wealthier suburb in her home city of Akron, Ohio, in the hopes of pulling of them out of their own dangerous and poor performing school district.

"Because of her 'crime' of manipulating school residency requirements, Williams-Bolar spent nine days in jail and will have to serve two-years probation, as well as 80 hours of community service. Moreover, because of her felony conviction (yes, I said felony), Williams-Bolar now faces the prospect of losing her job as a teaching assistant at a local high school, as well as getting kicked out of the University of Akron where she is one semester shy of completing her education degree.

"The injustices in this story are plenty: first, we have the overzealous Ohio prosecutor, who chose to relentless ly pursue a criminal conviction against Williams-Bolar when other parents who’d done the same thing were not criminally charged. While it’s hard to conclusively say if this prosecution was racially motivated, you do have to wonder why the prosecutor ’s office absolutely refused to cut a deal with Williams-B olar and let her plead guilty to a lesser misdemeanor charge.

"Then there is the issue of how public education is funded. Like many other states nationwide, Ohio primarily funds its education on the basis of property taxes, thereby ensuring that neighborhoods with higher home values have more money for education than schools in lower-income communities."

As columnist Charing Ball noted, our public schools are more racially and economically segregated today than they were when Martin Luther King, Jr. was shot. And there is an achievement gap between white students and African-American and Latino kids, which appears we are wringing our hands over rather than tackling head-on.

In the meantime, some families like Williams-Bolar's are illegally registering under other addresses to enroll their children in better school districts, as this columnist in the Washington Post noted. Personally, I know of two Latino families in nearby Richmond, California, who send their kids to Berkeley public schools either by lottery or registering under someone else's address. Richmond High School is infamous and has been made into a movie with Samuel Jackson as well as received national notoriety for the gang rape of a 15-year-old girl. I'll just come out and say it: if I were these moms, I would flee, too.

Sure, it's illegal. But if we are as free and equal-opportunity as we profess to be, then it shouldn't be. As WaPo columnist Kevin Huffman pointed out, prosecuting parents like Williams-Bolar is "America's version of the hungry man stealing bread to feed his family, only to have his hand cut off as punishment."

Ideally, all our public schools would be created equally. But they aren't. As long as this inequality exists, we shouldn't expect poor families in poor school districts to wait for us to finish debating on how we should proceed. At the very least, we should knock down this barrier now.


The views and opinions expressed in this post are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect those of MomsRising.org.

MomsRising.org strongly encourages our readers to post comments in response to blog posts. We value diversity of opinions and perspectives. Our goals for this space are to be educational, thought-provoking, and respectful. So we actively moderate comments and we reserve the right to edit or remove comments that undermine these goals. Thanks!