Cynthia Liu

    Snack Does Not Equal Sugar

    Posted April 21st, 2012 by

    This story originally appeared in the LA Moms Blog.

    Yes, I’m the resident Sugar Nazi at my school, the parent who complained when a Halloween celebration involved kindergarteners nibbling powdered sugar donuts tied with string off a clothesline using only their mouths. I’m a wet blanket, I’m here to rain on your parade.

    I’m the parent who marvels at the affluent Chinese immigrant parents at the weekend Chinese school in the community next door who haven’t gotten the memo yet about the high fructose corn syrup in the snacks they persist in bringing every week. (These performance-oriented, high-striving immigrant parents who are pouring advanced math sets and Mozart violin concertos into their kids at a young age along with artificial colors and bad-for-you-sweeteners–incongruity, thy name is San Gabriel Valley parent.)

    I don’t feel there’s a problem with “Snack Time Never Ends,” as this NYT piece claims. It’s not frequency that’s troubling, it’s something else. The article’s writer says:

    What is especially baffling where I live, in Los Angeles, is how often the kind of parental paranoia that obsesses about school ratings, vaccines and myriad imagined plagues is matched by utter disregard for the nutritional downsides of mowing down Fruit by the Foot every afternoon at 4. Rarely do I see a parent show up on the soccer field with a homemade snack, or even a bag of carrots. Oreos are the post-game snack of choice, even in sports leagues dominated by upper-income parents.

    Indeed, what happened? I know these upper-income moms, I’ve sent my child to school with their kids. I’ve seen the care with which super-nutritional toddler snacks are packed and lovingly doled out among stay-at-home moms in playgroups and by nannies in posh neighborhood parks. The infant food made with a food mill at home from organic “super-foods.” Did we all just decide that once elementary school or higher kicked in, our kids no longer needed to snack on carrot sticks?

    See, my problem is not with the ubiquity or the frequency –- it’s the quality. As one mom pointed out, especially for very young children, snack time is a crucial tantrum-stopper. For older kids at sports practice it’s an energy-picker upper. I just think it’s a huge mistake to think snack=dessert. And I have to admit, my pet peeve is when snack=sweet baked good.

    Now, I’m not going to pretend my kid has never touched a french fry or partaken of that crime against innocent seafood, popcorn shrimp. He’s not unacquainted with the cavity-magnet, Fruit Roll-Ups. He recently had the outlandish idea that we install a chocolate fountain in our kitchen. A few vices, a few indulgences here and there, make a person interesting and human.

    But at every snack? Please, no.

    I secretly conducted an experiment among the children at the intense Chinese school where we send our son every Saturday. I brought in fresh sliced apples and a supermarket pre-assembled vegetable platter with a little container of dip in the center. I brought extra mini boxes of Hansen’s apple juice on the theory that thirsty kids will drink two or find a water fountain if they’re still thirsty after one, and 30 half-drunk juice pouches with liquid still sloshing around inside are a waste.

    The children, who ordinarily are presented with old school Capri Suns (the “original” flavors you get at Costco, occasionally in blinding bright blue “flavor”), cookies, mini frosted donuts, or other such sweets, GOBBLED THE APPLE SLICES AND VEGETABLES like they were going out of style. They. Were. Happy.

    And you know what else? THE PARENTS AND TEACHERS were fighting the kids for celery sticks. I swear I saw the Chinese school’s teacher pushing her finger along the bottom of the dip container to get the last little bit.

    Join me. Stand with me in my nutrition revolution. Refuse to bring baked goods that take a long time to make. Buy string cheese or assemble fruit slices or veggie platters (often cheaper than donuts to feed 30). If it’s a fact that kids are grazing and sit-down meals can require the multi-tasking of an air-traffic controller to coordinate, then let’s make sure snacks–mini-meals–are good stuff.

    Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...
    Posted Under: Uncategorized


    April 27, 2012 at 12:50 am by teenagers

    I appreciate, result in I discovered exactly what I used to be looking for. You’ve ended my four day long hunt! God Bless you man. Have a nice day. Bye


    April 21, 2012 at 11:48 pm by JZ

    Yes, yes, a thousand times yes! I am “that parent” at my children’s school… An affluent, private Jewish school where food must be kosher. Kosher for goodness sake! You know, to teach kids to eat with INTENTION, to THINK abut what they are putting in their bodies. I guess God doesn’t want us to eat meat together with milk, but chocolate and challah are clearly soul mates since my three year old is given a bag of chocolate chips to mix in with his challah dough every Friday morning. My kindergartner went to care for his class’s organic garden last week and then was given a bag of candy and chewing gum to celebrate the sweetness of an upcoming holiday. Um, my five year has never had gum, thank you very much. How about a piece of fruit for sweetness? I do a little experiment of my own each year on my boys’ birthdays. Typically parents bring in cupcakes and candy and the kids go sugar crazy to celebrate. When it’s our turn, I do a make-your-own-yogurt-parfait bar and bring in yogurt, berries, and granola. After three years of this, I now know to buy in bulk…the kids and the teachers LOVE it! They always ask for seconds, and the teachers typically thank me for bringing in something healthy. I even had a parent thank me for getting her son to try yogurt for the first time. I just don’t understand how these wealthy, educated parents continue to send in such junk for their kids. Their snack bags have cookies and chips in them, their lunches have pudding and candy for dessert. How could they think that is brain food for their children? Why doesn’t it bother them? And why is the school continuing to allow it given all the current research on childhood obesity and diabetes? It is one of the major gripes I have with our school, and I plan on continuing to fight for a healthier environment for my kids.


    April 21, 2012 at 11:47 pm by Ginger Perry

    Well said! Snacks for kids (and actually, people of all ages!) should be veggies and protein, whenever possible. Fruits and juice are ok, but not ideal. Sweet baked goods are for the occasional dessert and special events. White flour and white sugar are NOT good for us, especially for growing people.
    Thank you for saying what A LOT of moms are thinking, but are afraid to act on, for fear of being shunned by our own kids, or being labeled the “health nut”. Carry on, celery-stick and string cheese wielding moms and dads!


    April 21, 2012 at 11:07 pm by Darcy

    Were we at the same Halloween party? I swear you are writing about Ann Arbor public schools! I’m the dreaded Food Allergy Awareness mother at our school – and I nearly had a heart attack when I saw the powdered donuts on a string!!! And supposedly “snack” at our school is supposed to be fruit or veggie. I’m also concerned about the kids coping with ADHD (avoiding casein and gluten), or Diabetes! Or the Vegans in the group! Not just those with food allergies. I ask: since when did every celebration or award (or math lesson) in school become FOOD-(sugar)-centric? I don’t recall bringing in cake for every single kid’s birthday when I was younger… we even had a “Candy Buffet” for one child’s birthday!



    1. Food Revolution! A Blog Carnival On School Food and Fighting Childhood Obesity, Diabetes « MomsRising Blog
    2. School Rules= Lower Obesity « MomsRising Blog
    3. How to Get Kids to Eat Healthy: 5 Tips From Food Experts « MomsRising Blog
    4. Junk Free Schools: A Blog Carnival « MomsRising Blog

    Leave a Comment

    Your name is required
    An Email address is required

    Notify me of follow-up comments via e-mail