Wendy Cervantes

    No Child is “Illegal”

    Posted August 20th, 2012 by

    Anyone who has spent time with children knows that even the youngest kids are quick to absorb all that is being said around them. Thus, it is no surprise that children have caught on to the use of the term “illegal immigrant” when adults talk about immigration, and for children of immigrants, this has increasingly caused a great deal of confusion and fear.

    A new report by the Center for American Progress (CAP) takes a comprehensive look at the detrimental impact of federal and state immigration enforcement policies on children and families.  The report, written by Joanna Dreby of the State University of New York, lifts up the voices of children themselves—those whose families have been torn apart and those that live in fear of that threat every day. In addition to highlighting the economic and emotional impacts, Dreby also identifies emerging trends such as children entering the child welfare system due to immigration enforcement measures as well as the increase in “sudden single motherhood” among immigrant families due to the high rate of fathers being deported.

    Yet perhaps one of the report’s most troubling findings is that many of the children interviewed understood the term “immigrant” to be something negative and equivalent to “illegal.” As a daughter of Mexican immigrants, I find the growing trend of shame and fear among children in immigrant families very upsetting. I know the power of words all too well. When I was growing up I also struggled with fitting in and feeling accepted, and I recall wishing that my family was just “normal.” I grew up in a Midwestern city with very few immigrants, and I was the only kid in class whose parents spoke Spanish at home and whose father had something called a “resident alien card.” I can vividly remember how distressed I was at the age of five to think that my father was an alien and how my poor mother spent several hours trying to explain that the term simply meant that they were from another country not another planet. So while I did at one point worry whether or not my family was completely human, I never once thought that we were “illegal” or had reason to be afraid of the police.

    I am now not only incredibly proud of my immigrant heritage and my identity as a Latina, but I have also dedicated my career to promoting policies and programs that empower children of immigrants. It is clear that the messages our children are getting from the media, the broader community, and loud anti-immigrant activists are having a potentially long-term impact on how they view themselves, and this negative self-perception could transcend generations. It is simply unacceptable to have our children questioning their own self-worth or the legality of their existence because of the widespread use of hateful language that dehumanizes and criminalizes the very children who are going to be the driving force behind our country’s future.

    Children of immigrants are the fastest growing segment of the U.S. child population representing one quarter of all children in the U.S., and while the vast majority are U.S. citizens and others are undocumented, each and every single one will play a role in our future. We as a nation will only be a successful if our children believe in their own value and potential.  Policies that ensure access to a high quality education, healthcare coverage, and income supports for low-income families are essential to accomplish this goal. The CAP report also points to the need for a legalization process for immigrant parents of U.S. citizen children as well as modifications to immigration enforcement and child welfare policies to ensure family unity and parents’ ability to make decisions regarding their child’s care.

    But changing policy is only part of the solution. We also need to change the way we talk about our immigrant community so that all our children can have the confidence and motivation to realize their dreams. Thus, we must hold reporters, policymakers, and our own friends accountable for the words they use by helping them understand why the term “illegal immigrant” is so offensive. Changing the conversation will take time and may be uncomfortable at times, but there is simply too much at stake not to. For so many years, undocumented youth were terrified of revealing their status, but because of their courage and the recognition of their own power, they over time built a national movement behind being “undocumented and unafraid.” And today, those same undocumented youth are now lining up to apply for deferred action for childhood arrivals (DACA), a policy change that they helped bring about by refusing to let the rest of the world label them.

    Thus, I do indeed have hope for an America where we truly see each other and respect each other for who we are, where we came from, and where we are going together. And that means an America where we recognize that no human being —and certainly no child—is “illegal.”

     

    Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...
    * * * * *
    Posted Under: Immigration Uncategorized
    Permalink

    10 Comments

    January 9, 2013 at 12:34 am by Shaima Parveen

    Undocumented Mexican Immigrant Interview

    Hello Wendy,

    My name is Shaima Parveen. My 9th grade English class is currently working on a project centered about the concepts of empathy and misunderstandings (stereotypes, biases, etc.) in our society. I want to conduct a personal interview on the topic of undocumented Mexican immigrants and how they are misunderstood. I understand you may consider yourself a member of this group, know someone in this group, or work closely with people associated with this group. I have included my interview questions below. I would like to receive a response back by Thursday. Any help you can provide would be wonderful. Thank you so much for your time and participation!

    1) Many undocumented immigrants came to America for a better lifestyle. Others have fled to America due to oppression in their homelands. What about you? What motivated you come to America?
    2) Many Americans unconsciously use terms like “illegal aliens” to classify undocumented immigrants. Even in American dictionaries, undocumented immigrants are defined as “illegal aliens.” How do you feel about the use of such derogatory terms, used to refer to undocumented immigrants, like you? How would you react if someone called you an “illegal alien”?
    3) Some people believe undocumented immigrants are depriving Americans of jobs by accepting manual labor and other jobs Americans refuse to do for cheaper pay. Do you agree are disagree with this belief? Please explain.
    4) On October 10, 2012, a US border patrol agent shot 16-year-old Jose Antonio Elena Rodriguez. The border patrol agent claimed Rodriguez was throwing rocks at him and he was only defending himself from Rodriguez. Do you believe the border patrol agent was justified in killing Rodriguez?
    5) Have you ever experienced firsthand or witnessed victimization as an undocumented immigrant? Please describe your experience.
    6) Many Americans believe undocumented Mexican immigrants are after the economic benefits in America. Yet, they are unaware of the fact that most undocumented immigrants only receive meager salaries and live in considerably cheap apartments. How are your current living conditions? Do you live like most Americans?
    7) According to most Americans who oppose undocumented Mexican immigrants residing in the U.S., “America is a land of laws.” Is it always important to abide by the law even under such circumstances? Please explain.
    8) Do you have any children that are native-born U.S. citizens? If so, do they receive the same treatment as you do in American society? Please explain.
    9) In the TV series 30 Days, directed and hosted by Morgan Spurlock, two groups who have opposite stances on an issue are forced to live together. In the episode “immigration”, Frank George, a minuteman who is passionate about ending undocumented immigration, is forced to a live with a family of undocumented Mexican immigrants. Frank George is an immigrant of Cuban descent who has crossed the border legally with proper documentation. Do you feel that Frank George, who is of Cuban descent, is a hypocrite for wanting to end illegal immigration? Please explain your answer.
    10) Do you want to be better understood by Americans? Why or why not?

    [Reply]

    November 25, 2012 at 1:35 am by Angelica

    Thank you Ray for your compassion for chdrilen around the world, for your generosity, and for taking Loving Hugs under your wing to fly us to new heights of increased awareness about our organization because of your help through Cybermail Marketing!There is so much good news that I need to communicate often about, to a world of people, and your help through Cybermail Marketing is making that happen!Thank you for helping us realize a larger potential through your internet communications saavy and tools. You are truly a God-send!!~Wendy

    [Reply]

    August 23, 2012 at 6:12 pm by Sandy

    Okay, I’ll agree to use the term undocumented if you agreed to bring dignity to the life of a late term child that survives a botched abortion by declaring it a person, and not a thing that is neglected and denied healthcare until it dies.

    [Reply]

    August 21, 2012 at 12:54 am by Dolli

    Uh. Yeah. If you’re here “illegally” that makes you “illegal”. It don’t matter if you’re a kid or not.

    [Reply]

    Wendy Cervantes Reply:

    @Dolli, thanks for taking the time to read my piece. Your misunderstanding is a common one. The fact is that it is not a crime to be present in the U.S. without documentation and therefore not “illegal.” And therefore immigrants without documentation are not criminals just for being here without documentation, rather they are subject to removal as part of an administrative measure, not criminal enforcement measure. The Supreme Court clarifies this. From an article written recently by Charles Garcia, he writes, “Justice Anthony Kennedy, writing for the majority, joined by Chief Justice John Roberts and three other justices, stated: ‘As a general rule, it is not a crime for a removable alien to remain present in the United States.’ The court also ruled that it was not a crime to seek or engage in unauthorized employment.”

    Furthermore, Garcia reveals “that the term ‘illegal immigrant’ was first used in 1939 as a slur by the British toward Jews who were fleeing the Nazis and entering Palestine without authorization. Holocaust survivor and Nobel Peace Prize winner Elie Wiesel aptly said that “no human being is illegal.” We can certainly learn a thing or two from history and the danger of harmful words. And that’s the kind of thing we should be teaching our kids rather than spreading hate.

    [Reply]

    Anita Reply:

    This is one of the best, most concise explanations I’ve seen about this. Thank you so much, Wendy– I will be pointing people here to read this.

    [Reply]

    Anonymous Reply:

    @Wendy Cervantes, Well said. Thank you, Wendy!

    [Reply]

    August 20, 2012 at 5:59 pm by Mary Olivella

    This is such a great blog post. Thank you, Wendy.

    [Reply]

    August 20, 2012 at 5:07 pm by Lara

    This is great — I never thought through it carefully before. You need to be sure that when you write about this, state the correct phrase repeatedly. What’s the substitute?
    “Undocumented immigrant,” yes? Or is there yet another term that would be even better? We need new words in our minds and mouths, so we can make this important change. I need your coaching.

    [Reply]

    Wendy Cervantes Reply:

    @Lara, the best alternative is “undocumented” if you want to be specific about someone who lacks documentation. When talking about immigrants in general, another commonly used phrase is “New Americans.” Thanks for taking the time to think about this important issue.

    [Reply]

    Trackbacks

    1. Honoring the Voices and Voting Power of MomsRising’s Latino Community: A Blog Carnival Celebrating Hispanic Heritage Month « MomsRising Blog

    Leave a Comment

    Your name is required
    An Email address is required

    Notify me of follow-up comments via e-mail