Mary Olivella

    It’s a “fact” that Black women are ugly?

    Posted May 23rd, 2011 by

    We just heard about this appalling article in Psychology Today from our friends at ColorOfChange.org.  Gabriel (on their staff) gave us the go-ahead to share their email about this. Here’s what the ColorOfChange team writes:

    **************

    Nearly 20 years after a black parent documented how hard it was to hear, “Mommy, I want to be white,”1 Psychology Today reinforced the false and hurtful sentiment that Black women aren’t attractive.

    Last week they published an article claiming it to be scientific fact that Black women are less beautiful than women of other races,2 penned by Satoshi Kanazawa, who is notorious for hiding behind pseudoscience to promote discredited racist and sexist ideas.3

    By giving Kanazawa a platform and validating his ideas, Psychology Today dehumanized Black women and girls everywhere.After widespread public outcry, they removed the article from their website.4 But that alone won’t erase the damage they’ve done by validating these discredited ideas — the editors need to apologize, explain how this happened, and let us know that it won’t happen again. Please join us in demanding they do so immediately, and then ask your friends and family to do the same:

    http://act.colorofchange.org/sign/psychtoday

    Kanazawa’s article is flawed from top to bottom.5 Using a dataset from an unrelated study of teenagers, he draws the obviously false conclusion that Black women are “objectively” less attractive than women from other racial groups.

    Kanazawa has a long history of hiding behind pseudo-science to express racist and sexist views. He once wrote an article asking “Are All Women Essentially Prostitutes?” and another suggesting that the US should have dropped nuclear bombs across the entire Middle East after 9/11 because it would have wiped out Muslim terrorists.6

    So why does Psychology Today continue to give him a platform? Black women constantly face both subtle and explicit messages that they are valued less than women of other races —  messages that are especially damaging to Black girls. NowPsychology Today has served as launching point for yet another attack, this time in the name of science.

    Almost as if to cover up the racism inherent in his piece, Kanazawa says that black men are, “if anything more attractive” than their counterparts of other races because of “greater testosterone.”7 But even here Kanazawa relies on the same pseudoscience to describe black men in familiar terms — brutish, hypermasculine, oversexed, exotic. And that’s dangerous, too.

    He uses a modern-day version of the faulty logic used to dehumanize blacks as inferior for hundreds of years, from the social Darwinists and eugenicists of the 19th century to The Bell Curve just 15 years ago. Psychology Today has a responsibility not to give such false logic a stage, nor validation.

    To undo the damage it’s done, Psychology Today needs to explicitly reject Kanazawa’s ideas. Please join us in demanding that their editors apologize, explain how this article was published in the first place and what they’ll do to ensure it won’t happen again in the future. It takes just a moment:   http://act.colorofchange.org/sign/psychtoday

    1. “Growing Up in Black and White,” Time, 5-17-1993
    http://act.colorofchange.org/go/828?akid=1987.1041105.ktFRKi&t=8

    2. “Why Are Black Women Less Physically Attractive Than Other Women?” Psychology Today, 5-15-2011
    http://act.colorofchange.org/go/829?akid=1987.1041105.ktFRKi&t=10

    3. “The Illustrious Career of a Crap Psychologist,” Jezebel
    http://act.colorofchange.org/go/830?akid=1987.1041105.ktFRKi&t=12

    4. “The Pseudoscience of “Black Women Are Less Attractive’,” ColorLines, 5-17-2011
    http://act.colorofchange.org/go/831?akid=1987.1041105.ktFRKi&t=14

    5. See note 3

    6. “How to Debunk Pseudo-Science Articles about Race in Five Easy Steps,” Racialicious, 5-17-2011
    http://act.colorofchange.org/go/832?akid=1987.1041105.ktFRKi&t=16

    7. See reference 2

    Photo by Angela7Dreams|Flickr

    Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...
    * * * * *
    Posted Under: Uncategorized
    Permalink

    6 Comments

    July 14, 2011 at 7:20 am by Jacob BLACK

    Honestly, I think you’re just as predjudice as the Japanese guy Karawjeja (however you spell his nam)). If the article is trash why bother spreading it so people can read it? Just bury it and move on. And why is the first response commebt so sizzled with hatred towards Black women and it was left up here? You responded to another comment on here (and there are only 5) so you obviously read it and decided to leave it up.

    You’re using the article to say what you really feel about Blacks yourself and pretending to oppose it.

    P.S. Hatred of others comes from a hatred of SELF.

    [Reply]

    Anita Reply:

    Please be a little more careful about ascribing intent. You’ve misread the article.

    [Reply]

    May 23, 2011 at 8:02 pm by Dzifa

    Hatred, stereotypes and racism come in so many forms, and this time within the guise of a “scientific” article. These are not the messages that I want any of our children to grow up with. I hope that one day when I have my own I will send more positive messages. There is so much beauty in the world in spite of this kind of ugliness.

    [Reply]

    May 23, 2011 at 7:36 pm by Laurel

    Where is the article that appeared in Psychology Today?

    [Reply]

    hanashi Reply:

    @Laurel,

    It is in the references/notes link 4.

    [Reply]

    May 23, 2011 at 6:55 pm by Anita

    “Mommy, I want to be white” (or, “I want to be [something else that's genetically impossible]“) would be such a painful thing for a parent to hear.

    I remember reading Toni Morrison’s The Bluest Eye; she wrote so clearly about the profound pain of the little girl who wanted to be white like her peer. And Morrison captured the family and social contexts so well, too.

    I’m glad to see this ColorofChange petition.

    [Reply]

    Leave a Comment

    Your name is required
    An Email address is required

    Notify me of follow-up comments via e-mail