Lynn Tramonte

    On Violence Against Women Act, GOP Works with Mail Order Bride Industry Against Immigrants

    Posted May 18th, 2012 by

    Cross-Posted at America’s Voice:

    “Russian Women are no longer the best kept secret of the cold war” notes the website of Encounters International, the mail-order bride company that is lobbying hard for the passage of the scary Republican version of the Violence Against Women Act (VAWA) — the version that passed the House of Representatives earlier this week. An actual reauthorization of VAWA passed in the Senate last month by a 68 – 31 margin, in a rare show of bipartisanship.

    As I previously reported, the VAWA reauthorization provides Republicans with a unique opportunity to advance a war on two fronts (fighting women and immigrants), and they’re taking it. One would think that some problems—like domestic violence—are just too universal a struggle to fall prey to politics. Sadly, the Republicans’ handling of the Violence Against Women Act proves that’s not the case.

    Incredibly, rather than protecting all people from abuse, they are doing the bidding of Encounters International and other “men’s groups” who are lobbying hard for the Republican VAWA bill. Why do these groups care? They’re lobbying for provisions that empower abusers and make it harder for victims of domestic violence to leave an abusive situation. See, immigration status and the fear of deportation give abusers just another tool to wield against their victims, and that much more leverage to make them stay.

    As Mony Ruiz-Velasco, National Immigrant Justice Center’s director of legal services, told the Daily Beast:

    “I’ve never had a case where the abuser did not use … immigration status as a tool.”

    They tell women that going to the police means deportation and separation from their children. And rather than recognizing their role in this problem and working to correct it, the mail order bride industry is actually lobbying Congress to give abusers more power and more control.

    As Rachel Maddow explained in her expose Wednesday night:

    One of the worrying aspects of the whole mail order bride phenomenon – not just now, but always – is that a woman who immigrates to the United States using a service like this can end up dependent for her immigration status in this country on the American man to whom she has just been married for a fee. And if that American man starts beating her up, an immigrant woman who came to America under these circumstances can kind of be trapped. I mean, you don’t want her to stay with the abusive guy who bought her hand in marriage on the internet. But if she leaves the abusive American husband, she also may lose the marriage tie that was making it legal for her to be here, and she would therefore get deported.

    So that’s the choice – right, stay with the man who was beating you…or get deported.

    House Republicans claim that they are trying to protect women, but their group is opposed by all the major national, state, and local domestic violence groups. The only groups that are gung-ho about the Republican version of VAWA are really, really sketchy.

    From the Huffington Post:

    The advocacy group, Stop Abusive and Violent Environments, or SAVE, has been lobbying the House of Representatives to include a “reform to curb VAWA immigration fraud” in its version of the bill. The GOP version of the bill does that by removing confidentiality protections for immigrant victims of abuse and forcing them to tell their alleged abusive husbands that they’re applying for protected immigrant status. It also removes an avenue through whih immigrant victims can achieve permanent citizenship.

    An official of SAVE has a major financial interest in reducing immigrant protections: Its treasurer, Natasha Spivack, started international “marriage service” Encounters International in 1993 with the aim of arranging marriages between U.S. men and Russian women. “The Woman Of Your Dreams Just May Have A Russian Accent,” states the company’s website.

    One of the Russian brides matched by Encounters International sued the firm, claiming that she was beaten by her American husband, that the company failed to properly screen candidates and neglected to tell her about a law allowing immigrants to escape abusive marriages without fear of automatic deportation. A jury decided in favor of the Russian bride and awarded her $434,000 in compensatory and punitive damages. The case was affirmed upon appeal.

    And so on. Back in February, when the Senate was first taking up VAWA, a letter was sent from a group called the Concerned Women for America Legislative Action Committee.

    “We, the undersigned, representing millions of Americans nationwide, are writing today to oppose the Violence Against Women Act (VAWA). This nice-sounding bill is deceitful because it destroys the family by obscuring real violence in order to promote the feminist agenda,” the letter read.

    Please note that “We, the undersigned” from the Concerned WOMEN for America Legislative Action Committee comprises mostly men. Of the twenty-five people who signed the letter, sixteen are male.

    In an exchange between Representative Sandy Adams (R), who introduced the bill in the House, and Representative John Conyers on the House floor Wednesday, Conyers asks “Who supports the Republican version of the bill?”

    Representative Sandy Adams can only respond with “Well, Mr. Conyers, I can say I do. And I know that we have a list of them…”

    Responds Conyers, adequately:

    I ask who’s supporting the Republican measure, and you say ‘I am.’ Well, I’m glad to know that. And I think that just about tells everybody where the logic and the support for this bill is – there is none.

    Unless, of course, your dating profile is: Republican, male, single, seeking Russian bride

    Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...
    * * * * *
    Posted Under: Immigration Uncategorized
    Permalink

    1 Comment

    October 8, 2012 at 6:24 pm by Paul

    SHAME ON YOU LYNN.
    You doggone well know that the original VAWA law was used as a weapon against well-intentioned men and supported immigration fraud, all by unrepentant man-haters such as yourself. Ever why we’re angry? Your bigotry against men, not to mention Russians and people of other nationalities, shows no bounds. You well know that Ms. Fox committed blatant immigration fraud that caused her husband to face criminal charges. While he was cleared of that, he and Ms. Spivack were not in a civil suit, losing millions of dollars even though they were innocent! AND YOU WONDER WHY THEY FORMED AN ANTI-VIOLENCE ANTI-VAWA GROUP? Good heavens, you are so dense! If you weren’t so bigoted against Russians, you’d know that Russian women WANT TO GET MARRIED, and since there are so few desirable men in their homeland they try to explore their options. So, why would you DENY WOMEN WHAT THEY WANT? Your feminist extremism is one reason American men get so frustrated, some of them (ONLY some) resort to beating up their women, which is wrong. How about you START RESPECTING MEN? I can say, having personally been acquainted with Russian women, even in their country and their homes, that they are far more like real women and great people than foam-at-the-mouth feminists like you. Men are not mere trophy pieces. We like and want women who are pretty, kind, respectful, and seek the same things we want…..which is a family and children. Men and women have defined roles. Women are NOT supposed to act and dress like men. Neither are men to be like women. We have different roles, yet were meant for each other. So for you to say men don’t have any business fighting disgusting things like domestic violence, it is you who is despicable. I see it everyday; American women acting uncouth, selfish, dressing poorly, and demanding things that make them happy, at the expense of others. I’m a true progressive who is ashamed of lousy politicians like Senator Masha Cantwell, who at age 50 remains UNMARRIED and living with daddy. Who’d want a woman like her? If you ever peruse any Russian so-called “mail order bride” site, maybe you’ll realize we American men are simply fed up with American women and choose to seek elsewhere for the right domestic companion that makes both of us happy. One that is too beautiful and too charming to ever abuse. One who we’d kiss and tell them we love them every day, and they DON’T act offended like American women.

    [Reply]

    Trackbacks

    1. GOP’s Version of VAWA’s Choice for Immigrants: Stay With Your Abuser or Get Deported - Hispanic Politico
    2. To Rep. Sandy Adams: Victims of Domestic Violence Deserve Better Than Your VAWA Bill « MomsRising Blog

    Leave a Comment

    Your name is required
    An Email address is required

    Notify me of follow-up comments via e-mail