“Federal Deficit 101″ for Anxious Parents
Posted June 30th, 2011 by Ashley BoydThe constant drumbeat in the news about the federal deficit and its potentially dire consequences for our country has parents like me nervous. The last thing I want is to leave my two precious children with a crippling debt that will limit their future security and prosperity.
I don’t have much time for new research projects (this is an understatement!) but I reached the point at which staying ignorant about our deficit – both what caused it and what we can do to get out of it – didn’t feel like an option any more. After putting aside the heated rhetoric from both sides of the aisle, I uncovered some useful, fact-based resources that are helping me get my head around this complicated situation.
For you fellow anxious, no-time-to-spare parents, I share the beginnings of my research.
Question #1 — Are we broke?
This question requires a two-part answer. First, there is no doubt that every level of government – local, state and federal – has been cutting spending in response to a decrease in sales and income tax revenue during the economic downturn. According to the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, the recent recession brought about the largest collapse in state revenues on record and for the upcoming fiscal year, 42 states and the District of Columbia are projecting a shortfall of $103 billion.
At the same time, we’re hearing a lot about our growing federal deficit. Interestingly, our federal deficit is a problem that pre-dates the economic downturn and isn’t related to runaway federal spending on social or “entitlement” programs. In fact, a December 2010 report from the bi-partisan Congressional Research Service noted that in just a few short years, our country moved from having budget surpluses to increasing our debt as a result of spending $1 trillion on the tax cuts enacted in 2001 and 2003, the increase in defense spending for the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan, and the costs associated with the Medicare prescription drug benefit enacted in 2003.
No matter what the cause, our current deficit situation is indeed scary. According to the non-partisan Congressional Budget Office, the federal deficit is projected to hit $1.3 trillion this year.
If our deficit continues unchecked, we will spend more and more money just paying the interest on our debt, squeezing our spending in all other areas such as defense, education and Social Security. Addressing the consequences of a growing deficit, the bi-partisan National Commission on Fiscal Responsibility and Reform wrote in its December 2010 Report: “America cannot be great if we go broke. Our businesses will not be able to grow and create jobs, and our workers will not be able to compete successfully for the jobs of the future without a plan to get this crushing debt burden off our backs.”
Question #2 - Are proposed cuts to social programs actually going to reduce the deficit?
If we are even going to consider terrible cuts to important programs, I want to know they are actually going to work. My nightmare is that we’ll make drastic cuts to programs, people are suffer and the cuts don’t end up saving money at tall (or worse, it will cost us more in the end). Based on my research, there is reason to be concerned that unwise budget cuts would cause long-term problems.
Let’s consider the proposed cuts to Medicaid as an example. Currently, Medicaid provides health coverage for approximately 60 million people, including children from low-income families, adults with significant disabilities and the elderly who require long-term care. Some in Congress are suggesting dramatic cuts in Medicaid in next year’s budget, which could result in millions losing this coverage.
You don’t have to be a health policy expert to realize this means many people will not be able to afford preventive care and treatment in the future will be more costly for all. For example, research shows that children who have health coverage are 3 times more likely than an uninsured child to have seen a doctor recently and five times less likely to need to use the Emergency Room as a regular place of care.
Before we consider serious cuts to programs that provide health care, nutrition and education for people, it seems pretty important to make sure that we’re cutting everything and anything that falls into the category of ‘wasteful spending”. Interestingly, the same political leaders who propose drastic cuts to helping families insist that our nation has enough money in our federal budget to spend billions to give tax breaks for millionaires, should ignore bi-partisan recommendations to cut nearly a trillion dollars of unnecessary defense spending, and should continue providing $40 billion in giveaways to Big Oil at a time when oil companies are making record profits on sky-high gas prices.
I certainly have a long way to go before completing my “Federal Deficit 101″ course! Each “answer” only spawns more questions. Join me in this adventure and we’ll learn more together.
What questions do you have?? Please share them now by adding a comment to this blog and we’ll have top experts address them during our Facebook chat on Thursday, July 7th from 12:00-12:30 PST on our MomsRising Facebook page.
Don’t worry- your thoughts don’t have to be the well-formed opinion of a full-time economic expert. Your experience as a caregiver (or child of a caregiver!) gives you the right to speak up and ask your questions. Share your thoughts below!



6 Comments
April 20, 2012 at 5:27 pm by David HallObama has passed the highest budget deficits as a percentage of GDP in recent history.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Revenue_and_Expense_to_GDP_Chart_1993_-_2008.png
This was after he said he was interested in reducing the deficit before he was elected.
[Reply]
July 7, 2011 at 9:39 pm by thought_criminal“I certainly have a long way to go before completing my “Federal Deficit 101″ course!”
You most certainly got that right, hun. Though you seem to have all your left-wing talking points rockin’ and rollin’. Soros would be proud.
[Reply]
June 30, 2011 at 5:57 pm by Don L. MillerDear Ashley Boyd:
Don’t let the deficit scare you. Unfounded deficit fear is what the GOP leaders want — Keep in mind Japan has a monetary system similar to ours and Japan’s deficit as a percentage of GDP is more than double ours and will be getting much worse due to the recent earthquake — yet deficit hysteria isn’t being created in Japan and in fact Japan’s economy is expected to come roaring back due to the economic stimulus (increasing in the short term Japan’s already high deficit) required to repair the earthquake damage.
So the GOP is working hard to create unfounded deficit hysteria so they can dismantle needed social programs, shrink government (especially regulations), and defeat Obama by making the whole economy much worse by 2012. If the President was John McCain the deficit would be a non-issue now. If the GOP was seriously concerned about deficits they would have left taxes for the rich where they were in 2001 when Bush became president and was handed a $125 billion surplus. Instead of using Clintons’s surplus to pay down the deficit, they slashed taxes primarily for the rich, abandoned Clinton’s pay as you go policies, engaged it two wars and enacted a hug drug benefit, that primarily benefited the drug companies, without paying for any of their major misguided initiatives and increased the deficit directly from $5 trillion to more than $10 trillion while increasing the debt limit 7 times without any great debate or concern. The $4 trillion plus increase in the deficit under Obama is directly attributable to Bush’s great recession.
Don L. Miller
[Reply]
Ashley Boyd Reply:
July 5th, 2011 at 7:23 pm
@Don L. Miller, Thanks for sharing your perspective on the broader context in which this debate is happening!
[Reply]
This was an excellent summary of the current crisis we’re in and what caused it. Thanks!
[Reply]
Anonymous Reply:
June 30th, 2011 at 12:52 pm
@Sarah Nash – Thanks so much! There is so much more to learn and share on this critical topic!
[Reply]
Leave a Comment