Children Occupy Wall Street: It’s About Sharing. They get it! Why doesn’t everyone?
Posted October 13th, 2011 by Monifa BandeleWith no school on Columbus Day in New York City, organizers of #OccupyWallStreet (OWS) put out a call for children to join them in lower Manhattan for an OWS Children’s Assembly.
My kids and several of their friends attended, and worked their way into the inner-circle of children ranging in age from toddlers to teens. The children came from all over the city, representing diverse communities.
The meeting began with a question posed to the children, “Why are you here?”
My mind immediately began to recall quotes from all of those journalists and pundits who are always so completely confused about Occupy Wall Street. CNN anchor, Erin Burnette, after visiting and interviewing people at OWS said, “No one knows what they are protesting.”
Really?
News anchors like Erin could use some help from a few school children who were so clear about purpose, and percentages, it makes you wonder where she went to school.
One by one the children articulated what they understood was the bad behavior that had brought everyone out to say, “No, no, no.” Someone was not sharing.
Child: “We are here because it is mean not to share and the banks are not sharing.”
Child: “A few people control everything [and] are not sharing with everyone else, the 99%.”
Adults couldn’t believe how simple it all was. Greed. Kids don’t like it. Most of us, don’t like it. Why can’t mainstream media understand this disdain? Are they totally desensitized to greed? Were they in one of those really accelerated educational programs where they skipped Kindergarten and missed that curriculum on the principles of sharing?
As the New York Times recently reported, “When the protesters say they represent 99 percent of Americans, they are referring to the concentration of income in today’s deeply unequal society. Before the recession, the share of income held by those in the top 1 percent of households was 23.5 percent, the highest since 1928 and more than double the 10 percent level of the late 1970s. That share declined slightly as financial markets tanked in 2008, and updated data is not yet available, but inequality has almost certainly resurged. In the last few years, for instance, corporate profits (which flow largely to the wealthy) have reached their highest level as a share of the economy since 1950, while worker pay as a share of the economy is at its lowest point since the mid-1950s.” [1]
Kids get it.
Child: “Some people are not sharing and they control a lot of money that could help our schools and hospitals. And they are only like 1%.”
Child: “Banks are being greedy and so people lose their homes and jobs, and they get homeless.”
Luckily, our teachers and our parents taught most of us that no one has achieved the success they have on their own. And, it is downright rude not to share. We were taught that this particular type of greedy bad behavior not only made you look bad; it shines a negative light on your whole family and community.
On the way home, I asked my little group of protesters to write down what they thought of Occupy Wall Street and what they thought OWS was all about.
Nisa (11), “I thought OWS was very moving and inspiring. The moving part of it was that so many people were taking time out of their life to stand up for people in this country. They know that 41 % of Black children are impoverished and they’re saying that even though I don’t know those kids, I’m going to stand up for them anyway. The inspiring part is that hundreds of people are in a small space together and they don’t even know each other, but are willing to be in a small cramped space but still work together. If I see that they can do that, then I know I may not be able to do something as big as that, but I can definitely make a change. I think it’s about proving to the government and the banks that they
can’t just harm our society.”
Ixe (10), “It was pretty cool, and very exciting there were a lot of things going on. My favorite part was the dancing dragon and the drummers. Making the sign was also fun. Out of a score of 1 to 10, I give it an 8.
“It was about how the government is not listening to the people. It was a protest against a whole bunch of things I don’t know all the things but some of it is about how 1% of Americans are very rich, and 99% are poor and in the middle. People protest because the government isn’t really listening to the people. They want to be heard. They don’t tax the rich, they only tax the poor and the middle class, and they end up having less money. I hope the government realizes they are disrespecting the people. I don’t like the fact that the people need to sleep outside on the street and yell curses at Wall Street to make their point. I’m not sure its a good idea cause people could get sick from being out there especially the people under 17.
“I made a sign and held it up with the people, and I felt like I was doing a good thing by making a statement and a commitment hopefully the government will pay attention and things will change.”
I asked my own 12-year-old, Naima why she thought so many people in the mainstream media don’t understand the occupations. She said, “Sometimes people don’t want to understand that what they are doing is wrong. Especially, when they don’t want to stop doing it.”





19 Comments
October 18, 2011 at 11:56 am by elizabeth hallWe took our 7 year old daughter to the Occupy DC protest on Columbus day and came back with a video that we thought you might want to see. We also agree that it’s a great way to expose kids to democratic principles.
We’d love it if you posted it somewhere.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x12iOQYY0w8
[Reply]
October 14, 2011 at 5:55 pm by angelaHaving been down there Wednesday,, I cannot imagine why you would want to bring your kids into the midst of that group and expose them to the filth and excrement that litter the park from the protestors. It’s an absolute health hazzard there. Even the bathrooms of local businesses are getting trashed. I was also appalled by the anti-Semitic slurs coming from the crowds and the harassment that was directed towards NYPD. You may agree with their reasons for protest, but I would not take my children there to expose them to what I saw.
[Reply]
Larry G Reply:
October 16th, 2011 at 11:35 am
@angela,
I feel sad that your children might have the benefit of seeing and hearing, on the streets of our beloved nation, democracy in action. You undoubtedly know that Abraham Joshua Heschel marched hand in hand with Martin Luther King to stand up for what they believed was right.
I hope that the marches of the “99%” will help foster respectful and informed dialogue and lead to a more just and kind life in these United States of America.
You apparently wish to hoodwink your children into believing that the world is bereft of prejudice and problems; and, further, to learn your own apparent bias about what the 99% represent or believe. Herbert Spencer warned that “contempt prior to investigation” breeds ignorance.
Your apparent attempt to “protect” your children from the harsh realities of life is noble but might only perpetuate prejudices which we both abhor.
[Reply]
Anonymous Reply:
October 17th, 2011 at 12:11 am
Hi Larry, you might like to review a video that originated back in 1948, right after the World War II. It’s an animation so I think you will be able to follow it and maybe learn something from it.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mVh75ylAUXY
[Reply]
Larry G Reply:
October 17th, 2011 at 9:36 am
@,
Thanks for the 1948 video, about the values of freedoms (e.g. to assemble) and of capitalism(compared to other “isms”). The story is the “American Dream”.
The video’s conclusion, that we can achieve much “…working together to produce an ever greater abundance of material and spiritual values for all….” has, unfortunately been derailed.
The American Dream illustrated in the video has now become a nightmare “for all”, i.e. the 99%, their message being the “primal scream” of our democracy (the “primal scream” phrase attributed to Al Gore by Nicholas Kristof in his New York Times op ed “America’s ‘Primal Scream’” published Oct 15, 2011).
Kristof believes the current “critical issue” of the 99% is “economic inequity” and states that “The banks have gotten away with privatizing profits and socializing risks….” in contrast to what the video portrays.
The video’s promise was the reality in 1948, and Kristof points out that “considerable equality” and economic growth did occur through the 1970′s, but since that time, economic “… inequality has surged….” and economic growth has stalled.
Kristof writes, “there’s a growing sense that lopsided outcomes are a result of tycoons’ manipulating the system, lobbying for loopholes and getting away with murder” and further
suggests “misregulation” of the financial system in America has contributed to this inequity, stalled economy and the global economic crisis about which the 99% speak.
Yes! Excellent article on how young minds are being inspired by this movement and asking basic, critical questions of their government.
[Reply]
October 14, 2011 at 3:35 am by OmowaleExcellent and very cool article! Kids are so insightful and thoughtfully critical. Love ‘em!
[Reply]
October 14, 2011 at 12:50 am by Marie MurrayGreat article. This article on kids response to this movement is a teachable moment. Kids understand sharing and helping others. The saying that “kids learn all need to know in kinderstand” is so true on many levels. That is why they can relate to what’s going on wall street. I love the way you actually quoted what the kids said. It was very authentic. Remember, parents you are your kids first and most important teacher. Looking forward to future articles. Great pictures.
[Reply]
October 13, 2011 at 7:32 pm by AnayaI am really inspired by the children’s comments. Children know how to keep things simple and get straight to the point. They are the leaders of tomorrow.
[Reply]
October 13, 2011 at 12:17 pm by Carol AlexanderInspiring! You are from a generation of thinkers that is preparing a generation of thinkers who will create more generations of thinkers…who will continue to mold a positive world.
A seed of thought!
[Reply]
October 13, 2011 at 9:52 am by Ghana ImaniWONDERFUL! You are truly raising those kids right! Parents are the 1st & best educators. We must tell them, show them, guide them & empower them. Great job!
[Reply]
October 13, 2011 at 9:47 am by Shannon DruryA great post! My kids and I attended the opening day of OccupyMN in downtown Minneapolis on October 7. Kids understand the need to pool resources, to cooperate, to look out for one another–after all, it’s what we spend so much of preschool and kindergarten teaching them! They are the 99 percent, too.
I posted a photo essay about our participation on my own blog: http://theradicalhousewife.com/2011/10/the-99-percent-includes-kids-too/
[Reply]
Anita Reply:
October 13th, 2011 at 5:11 pm
Shannon, very cool. Thank you for sharing the link to your own story too!
[Reply]
What a great story, Monifa, and adorable pictures! It really is a race to the bottom out there — 70+ hour work weeks and no health insurance is the American Dream?? What? — that it is important that those in power hear from the rest of the public. Thanks for doing your part to help our democracy.
[Reply]
Anita Reply:
October 13th, 2011 at 5:11 pm
I want a Like button for your comment.
[Reply]
Trackbacks
Leave a Comment