An Open Letter to Sarah Palin from Working Moms
Posted October 18th, 2008 by Joanne BambergerDear Sarah,
I hope you don’t mind me calling you Sarah. I feel like we know each other so well, what with all the media coverage you’ve been getting in the last couple of weeks.
I know you’re really proud of the working motherhood arrangement you’ve crafted for yourself. But since the GOP has been holding you up as the shining beacon of model motherhood, I have a few questions for you. I think a few of the other moms I know do, as well. So I hope you don’t mind me asking! We could have a quick chat over a cup of coffee, or you could just E-mail me back — I know you’re killer on the Blackberry!
Katha Pollitt at The Nation already has posed some questions to you. And I really do want to know the answers to them. But here are a few others I’m curious about, as well:
1. If you’re elected vice president, what are you going to do to help all the other working mothers in America? You know, not all of us have the kind of support system of family and friends you do to take care of our kids, but we still have to work so we can afford food for the table, gas for our cars and the after-school day care arrangements because most of us don’t have nannies (we now know you did, at least according to your own words on this video).
2. If after several years of being vice president you discovered that you had been paid less than all the other vice presidents before you, would you be OK with not being able do anything about it? If you’re not sure, I know Lily Ledbetter would be happy to talk with you about that.
3. You say you’re going to be an advocate for special needs children, now that you have one of your own. What does that mean, exactly? Will you use the power of being second-in-command for fight for health care coverage that these children need, but many of their families can’t afford? Will you make sure that parents get all the information about special needs children and that the federal government will step up to the plate with some dollars to help achieve that? Will you be honest about your son’s challenges if he grows up in the spotlight of national politics?
4. When will you be able to tell us where you stand on issues so important to the millions of working mothers in this country? Recently, one story said that you are “unable to say at this time what [your] position is on federal policies relating to job protections and benefits for working mothers.” It sure would be nice if you’d let us know sometime in the next 49 days. Sooner rather than later would be great.
5. I know you’re a little busy at the moment, but since you’re asking so many of us to vote for you, we’d like to hear a little more about these issues and less about that Bridge to Nowhere, though I would like you to be a bit more honest about what you did with the money you didn’t spend on that bridge.
6. Oh, one other thing — I know you say you’re against “earmarks” for special pet projects, but that doesn’t seem to square with the reports that you asked for over $450 million of them in the last two years. Maybe you could just be straight with us about that one, too.
Feel free to call, E-mail or drop by. I’ll put the kettle on and Piper can hang out and play with PunditGirl. I know you think some of these questions are irrelevant, but I think it’s fair to ask how your motherhood experiences will impact your potential advice an a McCain administration’s policies on FMLA, child-care and fair pay.
I’m not Charlie Gibson, but I know we could have a really lively chat.
Sincerely yours,



12 Comments
October 22, 2008 at 8:04 pm by SuzanneJust stumbled across these questions (great ones, by the way), and the predictable conservative response: Nasty liberal feminists are just jealous because Sarah Palin has it all.
It turns out the way Gov. Palin has been able to have it all has been to bill it to the state of Alaska. The state paid her a per diem to stay in her home, closer to her children, and paid to bring them to the state capitol when she needed to come to the main office.
They paid to send her daughters with her on official trips, so that she could spend time with them.
I’m sure there are working mothers across this country who would love those type of job perks. Maybe Gov. Palin could elaborate on whether she thinks other working moms are entitled to the work-life balance assistance the state of Alaska pays for in her case.
[Reply]
October 19, 2008 at 3:05 pm by PunditMomA call for a VP candidate — the one who could be the leader of the free world at any moment if elected — to answer questions in an honest and forthright way about her stand on the issues is being bitter?
I don’t think so.
[Reply]
October 21, 2008 at 2:20 am by AnonymousI hope I can teach my beloved five-year- old daughter that “life doesn’t just happen to you”. Our behaviours and choices govern how our lives turn out and ultimately, our children’s welfare. We have to teach our daughters to make good decisions because the reality is that the stakes are higher if you are a girl. A women has to be prepared to take care of herself and anyone else that comes along (ie, babies). Why don’t feminists focus on teaching girls that the most important decision you ever make is who to make babies with and you better choose well? I made a lot of sacrifices to finish my education before marriage and to attain financial stability and a happy marriage before I produced children. My husband and I made major sacrifices so I could be home with my kids when they were small. I continue to invest in my relationship so that I stay married and I chose wisely in the first place. I didn’t make babies until I was married. My happy outcome didn’t “just happen”. Good behaviour and wise choices gave me a much higher probability for a happy life. Why don’t we tell women the truth? You create your own destiny. No government program will insure your children a good education or adequate healthcare. Who is going to pay for all of these social programs? I’m tired of paying for other people’s bad choices. I’m a recovering feminist and I have hope that the day will come when real women stand up and speak the truth. Our kids need us to get it together, ladies, and keep it together! If you receive your basic needs from the government, you will always be dependent on the public largesse. If you depend on yourself, no one can ever take it away from you……………or your kids. I care enough to tell young women the truth and I thank God that I had a mother that told me even though she had a baby at seventeen she wanted a whole lot more for me. Thanks, Mom, for telling me the truth. I know it seems like I wasn’t listening during all of those “talks”, but, I’m pushing forty now and I think I finally got it.
[Reply]
October 18, 2008 at 11:27 pm by AnonymousPay no attention to the bitter liberals Sarah. The inability of liberals to see that you are the embodyment of what they pretend to stand for, simply becuse you disagree on abortion is an amazing thing to watch. These women can’t get their heads around what they should feel about you so they lash out. Pretty basic self defense maneuver, but still fun to watch.
Liberals have always trended toward the petty, but when they are confronted by you they become confused and unsure about their loyalties. Deep down, they really want to be like you. They are desperate to be self reliant, confident, a wonderful mother and wife. Yet it is their inability to surrender anything at all that keeps them a bound up.
You are a great example to daughters everywhere. (even to liberal daughters, they just won’t realize it until they are older).
Thank you for your willingness to walk through this mine field. Noone lashes out like an emotionally confused woman.
[Reply]
November 1, 2008 at 9:31 am by Anonymous“It is not about what our country can do for us but what we can do for our country” JFK
Do American’s really want to be Socialists?
If yes, do they understand the next step is Communism?
If you went to college, in the first year you learned that Socialism is the first step towards Communism.
Now I ask you, do American’s want to be Communists?
Think About It America!
This election is not about women’s rights or anything else!
It is about FREEDOM!
[Reply]
October 31, 2008 at 9:08 pm by AnonymousI am a single mother. I have a degree and numerous certificates.
This year is the first year in 10 that I have had a vacation. I used exactely zero personal days this year, I am so reliable and accountable that I am openly the company “go-to” person. My daughter is a high school honor student, band drum major and reporter for our local paper.
I am paid far less than the men and “non-mothers” in my company. I have less benefits and more work.
The “non-mother” who blogged about the unfair circumstances in her work place, may want to look deeper for the true reason she is treated that way.
I feel sorry for people who may not be mothers and either never had one themselves or have forgotten what having one meant to them. Not because I think everyone should be a parent, but because I would hope everyone would understand that without mothers, our species would not exist. Without working mothers, our species would not exist.
[Reply]
October 31, 2008 at 8:53 pm by AnonymousIf you did not realize you have it made compared to woman you need to get a grip
[Reply]
October 20, 2008 at 3:52 pm by Yvonne DiVitaInteresting…”You say you’re going to be an advocate for special needs children, now that you have one of your own…”
That’s disturbing. So, is she saying she had to have a special needs child before she could relate to the challenges…and now that she does, she is willing to do someting to help other special needs families?
I think…ALL mothers feel the challenges (regardless of whether or not we’ve truly experienced them) of a special needs child. I think all children, but surely special needs children, deserve all the love and support society can share. And that’s key – sharing. The attention, the care, and…the wealth.
[Reply]
October 23, 2008 at 6:25 pm by AnonymousI am sick to death of accommodating working mothers. I cannot count the times work has been dumped on my desk because some mother has to flee the office because the school or the day care provider calls with an emergency. In some instances my works suffers because theirs took priority. Several years ago I was forced to do a woman’s work whose job I was told I was not qualified to do and were turned down for the position. This woman would leave on average of once a week. If I wasn’t qualified then why was I always given her work to do whenever she needed to leave for a child issue? Forget about it. I finally had a talk with my manager and told him if he continued to do this to me I’d take the issue to our HR department. If you can’t make it to work and stay at work, then stay at home with the kid(s) or have the school or day care provided call the father. Or here is an idea; don’t breed!
These days’ companies have to provide segregated areas for nursing women who have returned to work so they can pump their breasts. The state mandates time limits and guidelines but they are usually abused and not enforced because no one wants to look like an ogre. Here again others are doing the work of the new mother.
As for bringing the kid to work, please don’t. That does not work in a fast paces office. One day a co-work brought in her year old for the last three hours of the day because the sitter’s child had an emergency she had to attend to. The kid screamed most of the three hours. I was on the phone and the customer said to me: “How nice you can work from home”, I told her I was in the office and she pardoned herself saying she “assumed” I was working from home because she could hear a child crying in the background. Not to mention the mother didn’t get much work done as she spent most of her time tending to the kid.
Why should mothers be held to a different work standard than women who are not mothers or men? The fact that they are paid less than non-mother is because they not as accountable or dependable. Single and young mothers make less because they usually are not as educated or skilled as they non-mother counter parts. Sounds fair to me.
[Reply]
October 19, 2008 at 7:42 pm by AnitaI’d love to hear back from Gov. Palin on these questions. Every parent in the U.S. should have the same wonderful benefits she’s enjoyed.
It would be great to hear her stances on our MOTHERS issues, which would provide those essential protections to all working families in the U.S. (Check out our MOTHER pages to learn more about each issue.)
[Reply]
Leave a Comment