A Parent’s Decision to Empower thru Sports
Posted February 2nd, 2011 by Nancy Hogshead-MakarGetting a child into sports and keeping them there is one of the best decisions a parent will make. While your kids do it for the fun, research on the life-long benefits of a sports experience gives parents even more motivation to schlep kids to those practices. Contrary to the “dumb jock” myth, interscholastic sports participation has a measurable, positive educational impact on both boys and girls from diverse socioeconomic, racial, and ethnic backgrounds. Betsey Stevenson, an economist from Wharton, found that it’s not just that kids already destined to do well play sports, but that playing sports actually results in more education and higher incomes – for boys and girls. In addition, a sports experience changes a girl’s health trajectory; preventing heart disease, breast cancer, osteoporosis, tobacco and drug use, unwanted teen pregnancy, sexually transmitted diseases, depression and suicide. To date, the very best known protection from obesity into adulthood is a high school sports experience. Can I get a “wow!”?
Celebrate the Successes with National Girls and Women in Sports Day
So, it is with good reason that we take time to celebrate the short statute that has caused nothing less than a revolution in sports – and indeed in education. Today is National Girls and Women in Sports Day, a time to acknowledge where we are and thank those women and men who gave a good chunk of their professional lives to Title IX and athletics, including Donna de Varona, Christine Grant, Birch Bayh and Billie Jean King, to name a very few. Their life’s work has helped a generation of female athletes that have benefited from Title IX, such as Jackie Joyner-Kersee, Sheryl Swoops, Aimee Mullins, Jessica Mendoza, Abby Wambach, Jennie Finch, Lisa Leslie, Misty May-Treanor, Kerri Walsh, Sanya Richards, and Mia Hamm, who continue to inspire and encourage our nation’s girls to break down the barriers that limit their potential.
The Promise of Title IX Remains Elusive
In addition to our celebration, we need to keep expanding opportunities for girls to play and live physically active lives. The gaps are still substantial; high schools provide our daughters with 1.3 million fewer sports opportunities than our sons, and collegiate women have just 42% of sports opportunities, despite being 57% of the student body.
The Premise of Equality in Education and Sports Remains Popular, Despite Frequent Title IX-Bashing
The law enjoys enthusiastic support around the country. A recent Mellman poll, of over 1000 respondents, found that about 80percent of men, women, Democrats, Republicans, independents, and people with and without children all support Title IX. It seems odd that there are still voices that contest the premise of equality. And yet, a small group of people is out to convince us all that Title IX is what’s wrong with sports. It’s a one-sided pounding — men’s sports good, Title IX bad — particularly when a school regrettably drops a men’s sport.
Decision-makers dropped programs to avoid complying with the law in other contexts, and the comparison is worth noting. In the 1950s some communities chose to close swimming pools and golf courses, rather than integrate. The Supreme Court said the law just required equality, and that civil rights did not require communities maintained those pools, even if they closed them for racially-motivated reasons. Here’s the difference between the 1950s and today. Back then, the outrage for these unethical decisions went directly to those that closed the pools and golf courses — not to the law. How absurd to blame the laudable goal of racial integration. Yet some will foist indignation on the law when a school cuts a men’s program, rather than upon the school’s failure to plan for the inevitable 40-year growth in women’s athletics. Schools have enormous flexibility to comply with the law, and it never requires cutting any sport. While the Women’s Sports Foundation is heartbroken with the loss of any team (remember, we have fathers, brothers, husbands and sons too!) courts universally reject these “reverse discrimination” challenges, finding that men, as a class, were over-represented in the athletics department.
Despite the publicity received by these Title IX-bashers, the truth is that both men’s and women’s collegiate sports participation opportunities are increasing. In collegiate sports, 412,768 NCAA student-athletes participated; 57.4% male and 42.6% female. In 2009, the average number of student-athletes per NCAA school was 232 for men and 168 women. Since the 1990-91 academic year, female teams increased by 2,268, while male teams are up by 273. High school boys and girls participation figures also reached respective all-time highs with 4,455,740 boys and 3,172,637 girls in 2009-10.
Women athletes are heroes and mentors, leaders and role models. Each female athlete is a living affirmation of why it is important to ensure equal opportunity in sports. Athletes know that future success is built on past successes. National Girls and Women in Sports Day was started 25 years ago to take stock of the truly astounding gains in athletics, and to recognize where the gaps persist. If your daughter’s sports experience isn’t as equitable as her brother’s, you can call the Women’s Sports Foundation’s Advocacy line to get help, or visit our website to learn more at WomensSportsFoundation.org.
Olympic Champion Nancy Hogshead-Makar is the Senior of Director of Advocacy for the Women’s Sports Foundation, a Professor of Law at the Florida Coastal School of Law, and mother of three.



10 Comments
March 14, 2012 at 5:55 am by PoolsharpGreat article!
Sports indeed make a big difference in the college application come to think of it.
I see it as a FUN and COMPETITIVE way of teaching your child discipline and the importance of teamwork.
[Reply]
February 3, 2011 at 11:34 am by Aristotle CircleGreat article! It’s true that sports can make a big difference in the college application later on down the road. Teaching your child teamwork and discipline through athletics go a long way into shaping them to be an excellent college candidate.
[Reply]
February 3, 2011 at 11:10 am by ChrisWhile we can applaud the progress that title IX has made, like all things, we should be diligent in measuring the point where we feel equality has been made. Our persistence to squeezing title IX enforcement into every aspect of our lives may be driving a growing negative movement against it. This then contributes to our ever-increasing polarization of our society, where brotherhood and cooperation is shelved in favor of coercion and growing tensions among groups seeking to score the next legal victory against their neighbor. The question as we strive towards a 50-50 split on athletic programs is will it truly result in the end of our perceived discriminations; will the organization and money created to bring about this change finally fold and close; and what will truly be the cost to our society. My guess is that when the programs become equal, the money and organizations will continue and in order to sustain itself, they will rely on stirring fears based around the possibility of losing ground and paint our neighbors as something more evil than they really are.
[Reply]
Nancy Hogshead-Makar Reply:
February 3rd, 2011 at 11:32 am
@Chris, Title IX’s measurement for compliance by looking to the other gender is only appropriate in the unique sex-segregated world of athletics. The math department is gender-blind; applicants with the highest GPA and SAT scores gain admission. Sports, on the other hand, require an entirely new athletics program if girls are going to play en masse. (with boys’ extra testosterone, only a few girls would get to play.)
There seem to be some who think that equality isn’t fair – that men “should” have more sports than girls. I’d also like to keep the peace, but not at the expense of failing to give our daughters an educational experience that reaps life-long educational, economic and health rewards.
When I went to law school, I assumed I couldn’t practice in this area, because the quest would have already been completed. Ha! Yet Advocacy continues to be a slice of our work, like GoGirlGo! that gets underserved girls moving through community grants and our award-winning curriculum. We also have a research center at the University of Michigan that studies woman-sport issues. I could go on, but the point is that Advocacy is one part of the Women’s Sports Foundation’s work, whose mission it is to advance the lives of girls and women through sports and physical activity.
[Reply]
Because of Title IX, my girls are growing up in a different world than I did. They assume that they will play a sport every season and that their programs are as important as boys’.
I’d like to think that the Title IX bashers are fighting a fight that we’ve already won, but clearly that’s not the case. We all have to speak up in defense of Title IX whenever we can and not make assumptions about the future of girls’ athletic programs.
Nancy, you are one of my heroes. Thank you for ALL that you are doing on this important issue!!!!
[Reply]
Anita Reply:
February 3rd, 2011 at 11:58 am
@Emily McKhann, Terrific to see you here! We miss you!!! And it’s great to hear how involved in sports your girls are. Makes me wonder what it’s going to all look like when my own girls get to school-sports age.
And I can’t help but think about Tiger Mom and how she didn’t let her daughters play any sports. There’s probably a whole blogpost that could be written on that topic!
[Reply]
Emily McKhann Reply:
February 3rd, 2011 at 1:28 pm
@Anita, Hi there!!!!! I hope you’re doing well and your girls too!!!!!
Just a few years ago, my town started a lacrosse league for kids. Everyone was shocked when 100′s of kids showed up, many in kindergarten. Now you’d never believe the program is so new because there are girls and boys with lacrosse sticks everywhere – and the assumption that of course both sexes are participating fully. So great for our girls!
I have so many issues with the Tiger Mom approach, and yes, not allowing kids to plays sports is a big one!!!!
xoxo, Emily
[Reply]
Anonymous Reply:
February 4th, 2011 at 11:25 am
@Anita, I can’t help thinking about Tiger Mom too! We’ve talked a lot about it within my extended family – now that my siblings are all parents, we’re curious how my parents got us to work so hard in school. I have no memory of shouting wars, “you can’t make me!”
I think my parents sent us to Tiger Mom teachers and coaches. They weren’t Asian, but the attitude of joy coming from mastery would resonate with them. At the height of my training for the Olympics, I was in the water 25 hours/ week, plus weights, running and stretching. It wasn’t the first half-hour that was hard, it was the 2nd and 3rd hour… Now I have to add that kids do NOT need that sort of crazy dedication to reap the benefits of sports I talked about in the article.
Thanks for the idea Anita! Nancy
[Reply]
Nancy Hogshead-Makar Reply:
February 3rd, 2011 at 4:37 pm
@Emily McKhann, thank you Emily, my dear friend of 20 years! Should I have put in my tag line, “mother of 3 great kids”? A 10 y/o son and twin 5 y/o girls?
The people that don’t get the problem are always the young kids — they are too busy having fun in sports. Once I was giving a Title IX history talk to an all-boys high school, and one guy raised his hand and said, “what’s the big deal? all of our girlfriends play sports.” He didn’t say sisters or moms — it was these guys’ high school girlfriends. and the way he said it, he thought it was great. ahhhh, now we’re getting somewhere.
[Reply]
I like your article. thanks a lot.
[Reply]
Trackbacks
Leave a Comment